Conflict and Transcendence

Some con­flicts must be man­aged, mean­ing they con­tin­ue between peo­ple but they are not allowed to dom­i­nate the rela­tion­ship. We “agree to dis­agree,” we say. A more or less palat­able out­come at times that — in the­o­ry any­way — ends the con­test and inter­rupts dark­er feel­ings. I bet you’ve been there. So have I.

How­ev­er, it may still be worth­while to ask about the impacts of this agree­ment with dis­agree­ment. Some inten­tions are clear­ly good — to avoid ran­cor, for instance. But the agree­ment to dis­agree also large­ly means that vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty and learn­ing are both cur­tailed. There prob­a­bly won’t be any big new insight into the work­ings of anoth­er per­son or the work­ings of our­selves, no acknowl­edge­ment, for exam­ple, where we might have been wrong, no new or refined per­spec­tive or change to our behav­ior, no les­son. We may have worn out the con­flict but we have not resolved it.

000033870007

Sup­pose — and I think this is quite com­mon — that under all that non-change I con­tin­ue to oper­ate on the basis of ongo­ing neg­a­tive beliefs or assump­tions about anoth­er per­son­’s style and motives. Apply­ing this mind­set as a fil­ter wher­ev­er the oth­er per­son shows up, these assump­tions sub­tly, even uncon­scious­ly, con­tin­ue to col­or my views even if they are — by “agree­ment” — unspo­ken. Things seem okay, but are they? Part of the prob­lem is that through the prac­tice of agree­ing to dis­agree I may learn to sup­press my full feel­ings from my aware­ness — they only leak when I have a chance to com­plain behind the scenes.

An exam­ple. I hap­pened to be talk­ing with one of my clients, a very hard work­ing man­ag­er, and he con­fessed that every time a cer­tain employ­ee of his asks about my clien­t’s new baby, he hears an attempt to manip­u­late. They get along well enough, he says, but an under­tone is there. “He’s a fam­i­ly guy,” my client explains, “and he’s ask­ing me about my new baby — our first child — because he does­n’t want to work past five. He’s try­ing to con­vince me fam­i­ly should be so impor­tant. If I buy it he’ll be less on the hook for the hard work past five that his job requires. Obvi­ous­ly he does­n’t want me to work as hard as I do because then he might have to work hard, too.” (This is a true sto­ry. I’m not mak­ing it up.)

I’m sure you can sense the nature of the con­flict between these two man­agers, but there’s also an inter­nal con­flict for my client that may not be as evi­dent, one he gen­er­al­ly hides but is will­ing to share on this occa­sion. It’s clear he’s being hit by his employ­ee in a spot that’s a lit­tle ten­der. He acknowl­edges to me he’s work­ing out what it means to be a father. He acknowl­edges (and his wife has already pro­vid­ed this feed­back to him) that when­ev­er he picks up the baby it’s to a solve a prob­lem, not just to enjoy and love and cud­dle this new lit­tle per­son in his arms, his son. He’s pick­ing up the baby because the baby needs to be changed, because he’s cry­ing, because he’s hun­gry. Oth­er­wise, let him bond with Mom.

To treat a baby as an object in this way is trag­ic. And he can see an obvi­ous par­al­lel to his own man­age­ment style, a pat­tern that makes his issues more glob­al. He tells me that he’s at work to solve prob­lems, cri­tique oth­ers’ per­for­mance and cor­rect mis­takes — that’s his pur­pose. He fills in the tech­ni­cal depth when oth­ers don’t know what to do. He’s there to do the work him­self if it becomes nec­es­sary. He’s not there to relate to oth­er peo­ple, he says — and there­in lies the not so hid­den con­flict. When asked about his baby what he hears is that neg­a­tive assump­tion about his report’s motives. If he relates, he tells me, mean­ing he takes the ques­tion about his baby at face val­ue and as sin­cere, then he risks being used. And that’s an intol­er­a­ble thought.

So he silent­ly “agrees to dis­agree” about how much work a man­ag­er should put in, com­plain­ing about it in the back­ground even before any overt con­flict between the two of them emerges. He clings to a pri­vate and undis­cussed neg­a­tive assump­tion — which is to say he clings to his own avoid­ance by wrap­ping it in an unspo­ken insult he shares behind the scenes. In this way he stays out of the dark place that is core to the con­flict inside him­self. If the con­flict were out in the open, he might have to go through that most dif­fi­cult part of the jour­ney, the tight, per­son­al­ly vul­ner­a­ble space of see­ing some­thing about him­self as a per­son, a kind of tun­nel — which can tru­ly be quite a mys­te­ri­ous pas­sage for peo­ple, one often imag­ined to be more dif­fi­cult and painful than it actu­al­ly is.

Iron­i­cal­ly, some­thing can hap­pen on that jour­ney — if it is tru­ly embraced rather than avoid­ed or refused — some­thing that is as much about about for­get­ful­ness as about insight, as much about nepenthe, the myth­ic drug that alle­vi­ates sor­row as about under­stand­ing. This is because part of work­ing through con­flict means ulti­mate­ly sur­ren­der­ing some aspect of what we are so sure of in our neg­a­tive thoughts about oth­er peo­ple. At some point, maybe with­out real­ly being aware of it, some part of the feed­back com­ing our way gets through and we begin to sac­ri­fice — even for just a moment — the self-pro­tec­tive neg­a­tive assump­tions we’ve made about anoth­er person. 

I think this is often a more or less nat­ur­al reflex that enables human growth, almost a fac­ul­ty, one we are lucky to have. Los­ing focus on our neg­a­tive beliefs enables us to come clos­er to our­selves and the dis­cov­ery that it’s no longer about oth­er peo­ple and their moti­va­tions. It’s about us and our respon­si­bil­i­ties, who we are in truth, not who they are in our fan­tasies. The fac­ul­ty helps us stop pre­tend­ing. We stop believ­ing that we’re being gaslit or vic­tim­ized and accept some ker­nal of a truth that has been hard to see. Some would call this recov­er­ing a pro­jec­tion, but I’m not sure it’s always about Shad­ow so much as con­fronting scat­tered pieces of old con­di­tion­ing and fears that sim­ply haven’t yet been understood.

000033870010

Who knows exact­ly what real tran­scen­dence is and when it will come. It seems to me the best thing is to make all the feel­ings and wor­ries and neg­a­tive beliefs about self and oth­ers supreme­ly con­scious in order to look at them plain­ly and to pick through them care­ful­ly — and then — and this is crit­i­cal — to give it a rest, maybe even to sleep. Because it’s just insane to hold onto all that non­sense. It does­n’t help to cling and with a lit­tle let­ting go there’s a shift to a sim­pler heart.

Fol­low­ing the exam­ple above, some­day I hope my client will be able to say to his report exact­ly what he said to me:

Ah, my son. He is incred­i­ble and when he smiles he lights up the whole world!”

And let it go at that, rather than focus­ing on some sto­ry of how he’s being maneuvered. 

All those neg­a­tive, dark and dark­er beliefs we store up. All those assump­tions. All those fears of what could be done to us. It’s like rec­og­niz­ing that the com­pli­cat­ed pre-Coper­ni­can algo­rithms we have used to define how our uni­verse oper­ates are actu­al­ly incor­rect. I find I have been liv­ing an illu­sion. I real­ize I trav­el around the sun, not the sun trav­els around me.

Every con­flict I’ve ever known is filled with such over­ly com­plex cal­cu­la­tions, false par­a­digms, neg­a­tive beliefs that in the end are dis­cov­ered to hard­ly have sub­stance at all. If my work fails it’s because those in con­flict main­tain their place and sta­tus — and their sto­ries about one anoth­er — not risk­ing the true jour­ney but instead agree­ing to disagree.

By Dan Oestreich

I am a consultant, coach, facilitator and trainer supporting the growth and development of leaders and teams. For further information about my work and services, please access my Oestreich Associates website.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.