A Very Shy Wild Animal

Over at Whiskey Riv­er I found a stun­ning quo­ta­tion from Thomas Mer­ton’s book, New Seeds of Con­tem­pla­tion:
.

The false self con­sists of all of the efforts we make to nur­ture a rep­u­ta­tion for our­selves in the mind of oth­ers. In our cul­ture, we have a com­pul­sive need to be val­i­dat­ed by exter­nal sources. But the true self is one that is whol­ly sep­a­rate from this frag­ile image that we try to con­struct in the imag­i­na­tion of oth­ers. The true self is like a very shy wild ani­mal that nev­er appears at all when­ev­er an alien pres­ence is at hand, and comes out only when all is peace­ful, when he is untrou­bled and alone. He can­not be lured by any­one or any­thing, because he responds to no lure except that of the divine freedom.

The prob­lem with the machin­ery of the false self is that it is so eas­i­ly dis­turbed. With­out our pro­tec­tive fan­tasies about who we are, we believe we will expe­ri­ence pure per­son­al noth­ing­ness: the dark vac­u­um of emp­ty inner spaces at absolute zero. Such is the nature of the false self that it is found­ed on the belief there is noth­ing beyond its care­ful­ly con­struct­ed mirages and hopes of exter­nal val­i­da­tion. Indeed, in rela­tion­ships, we want that recog­ni­tion: men often look for the val­i­da­tion of women and women often seek the val­i­da­tion of men. Chil­dren need the val­i­da­tion of their care-givers in order to know they are (and will be) okay and as the chil­dren grow up, those same care-givers may also ulti­mate­ly look for their chil­dren’s approval. In orga­ni­za­tions, both lead­ers and fol­low­ers yearn to be “seen” and appre­ci­at­ed. We wear our cos­tumes and car­ry out our roles, hop­ing at the end of the play there will be recog­ni­tion, applause, good reviews. We base our stature on what we hope is our rec­og­nized con­tri­bu­tion. Some­times we are accu­rate about that lega­cy; some­times it may be only as real as a fan­ta­sy of win­ning the lottery.

In Zen Bud­dhism there are many metaphors that trace the con­di­tions for appear­ance of the true self. In phras­es such as “jump­ing right down the tiger’s throat,” “find­ing the bot­tom of the riv­er,” and “if you find the Bud­dha, kill him” there is encour­age­ment to go expe­ri­ence that “noth­ing­ness” for your­self, and in doing so break the chains that bind us to false­ness and exter­nal val­i­da­tion. As I read Mer­ton, he’s call­ing forth in this image of the very shy, wild ani­mal a vision of quite a hum­ble crea­ture — most­ly in hid­ing it would seem — that nev­er­the­less car­ries a seed of immea­sur­able strength. 

I like this vision because it places our capac­i­ty to lead in the cat­e­go­ry of learn­ing to get past a false self that is addict­ed to its blindspots. Some­times we mis­in­ter­pret with the thought that if only we can numb out our con­cerns for oth­ers and their per­spec­tives, learn to demand, incor­po­rate a cer­tain ruth­less­ness into our char­ac­ter, then the true self can show up. Some­times we mis­in­ter­pret by fail­ing to dis­tin­guish between our own prob­lems and the prob­lems of oth­ers. In both cas­es there is a denial of real­i­ty. This all seems to me to be the prod­uct of a cul­ture that over-val­ues indi­vid­u­al­ism and inner dis­con­nect­ed­ness, deny­ing expe­ri­ence. It is the prod­uct of a cul­ture that rou­tine­ly miss­es the point that the strength of the True Self is in its com­plete aware­ness and sen­si­tiv­i­ty, not the loss of con­scious­ness that is part of some inner emo­tion­al dis­con­nec­tion. In fact, it is that very sen­si­tiv­i­ty that dri­ves enlight­ened action, not the reverse.

There’s a sto­ry about two trav­el­ers in a very impov­er­ished coun­try that come upon a very sick child alone by the side of the road. It’s evi­dent that there is real­ly noth­ing to be done. The child will soon per­ish — per­haps in only a mat­ter of min­utes. The child is beg­ging for water. One of the trav­el­ers is ready to take out his water flask, but then quick­ly puts it away. “I will only pro­long the child’s agony,” he says. “The humane thing to do is hur­ry death, I’m afraid.” The oth­er trav­el­er, how­ev­er, drops to her knees and imme­di­ate­ly gives the child some water. She nes­tles the child in her arms. She qui­et­ly sings to the child and holds the lit­tle one close for over an hour until death final­ly comes. The first trav­el­er asks,“What good did you do pro­long­ing the child’s mis­ery? Now you and I are both delayed in our jour­neys.” “What good did you do as part of your own jour­ney,” she replies, “by learn­ing to deny this suffering?”

To deny suf­fer­ing — in our­selves and in oth­ers — is to be fright­ened and to run, avoid­ing the very shy wild ani­mal that goes by so many names. True Self is only one.

Technorati Tag:

By Dan Oestreich

I am a consultant, coach, facilitator and trainer supporting the growth and development of leaders and teams. For further information about my work and services, please access my Oestreich Associates website.

1 comment

  1. I stum­bled onto your web­site today while doing some search on self knowl­edge and lead­er­ship. My core self res­onates with your writ­ings, espe­cial­ly this one, which brings tears to my eyes. The con­cept of the deny­ing suf­fer­ing (pain is the word I pre­fer) is rarely under­stood, so fac­ing suf­fer­ing (oth­ers as well ours) has become a very lone­some jour­ney while suf­fer­ing is every­where. How ironic!
    Love your con­scious­ness approach to human devel­op­ment, for me, there is no oth­er way for real change, which is trans­for­ma­tion. Thank you for shar­ing your knowl­edge, I am very encour­aged know many oth­ers are trav­el­ing on the path.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.