Our Civil War

This is an emo­tion­al time for Amer­i­cans — what with the mar­kets crash­ing and the wan­ing days of the pres­i­den­tial cam­paigns. The air­waves are full of com­men­tary into the mean­ing of every small move on either sub­ject. And at every turn there is anoth­er sat­u­rat­ing bar­rage of side-tak­ing opin­ion. It is so appar­ent that our coun­try has a great deal of work to do now to recov­er itself and to reclaim its stature as a nation that rep­re­sents some kind of lead­er­ship. At one time the notion of this coun­try lead­ing meant some­thing about our eco­nom­ic well-being, mil­i­tary strength, and, most impor­tant­ly, our felt com­mit­ment to cre­at­ing a bet­ter world. Per­haps there was arro­gance in that notion of lead­er­ship, too, but I cer­tain­ly grew up believ­ing in the deep­er intention. 

In con­trast, today it is so clear we are in a peri­od of extra­or­di­nary “val­ues cri­sis.” The sides are about even and are polar­ized and are fight­ing. The stakes in terms of nation­al iden­ti­ty are extreme­ly high. We don’t know who we are as a coun­try — we do not have a uni­fied, lived view — only sep­a­rate sides defined by our val­ues sets, con­ser­v­a­tive and pro­gres­sive. The truth must be that the world is watch­ing us as we real­ly are, caught in this self-absorbed civ­il war. Per­haps it is not yet a “hot” one with vio­lence in the streets, but if it gets to that, I don’t think any­one will be sur­prised, giv­en the lev­els of anger sur­fac­ing in the cam­paigns. We are in a war with our­selves about the val­ues that we hold most dear, that we believe will keep us from harm, that will offer a sus­tain­able direc­tion, that may even be a legacy. 

Last week­end, I went for a long, qui­et walk in one of Wash­ing­ton State’s most beau­ti­ful rain forests. Instead of the tele­vi­sion and the com­pet­ing voic­es all there was to hear was the sound of inter­mit­tent show­ers and in between them the sounds of creeks and the drip of water from leaves of the turn­ing maple trees. In such a place, con­scious­ness of the war went away for awhile, replaced by what is time­less and beau­ti­ful and pro­found. I was remind­ed how in the inter­stices of the world the heart grows, and how impor­tant it is to lis­ten to that heart.

This a time in which it is imper­a­tive to feel and think for our­selves aside from all the chat­ter. What seems clear is that it is time to locate the raw earth of a new­ly uni­fy­ing Amer­i­can iden­ti­ty. We have to cut through the cur­rent polar­iza­tion the way the silence of the for­est cuts through it — to see it for it is, sim­ply an argu­ment that nei­ther side can win — to find out what we want to actu­al­ly stand for. That process could take us for­ward to our own def­i­n­i­tion of what is a good coun­try now. I have a feel­ing that if we all com­plet­ed this exer­cise the com­mon prin­ci­ples that would be artic­u­lat­ed, such as jus­tice and free­dom, would be much the same as they have been since the Founders, but the “how to to get there” might be very, very dif­fer­ent, par­tic­u­lar­ly in our rela­tion­ship with the rest of the globe.

In 2000, Ian Fra­zier pub­lished his excep­tion­al book, On the Rez, about the Oglala Sioux and the Pine Ridge Reser­va­tion. Along the way, he makes this com­men­tary, which in times like these I find comforting:

Amer­i­ca is a leap of the imag­i­na­tion. From the begin­ning, peo­ple had only a per­sis­tent idea of what a good coun­try should be. The idea involved free­dom, equal­i­ty, jus­tice, and the pur­suit of hap­pi­ness; nowa­days most of us prob­a­bly could not describe it a lot more clear­ly than that. The truth is, it always has been a bit of a guess. No one has ever known for sure whether a coun­try based on such an idea is real­ly pos­si­ble, but again and again, we have leaped toward the idea and hoped.…The idea does not tru­ly live unless it is expressed by an act; the coun­try does not live unless we make the leap from our tribe or focus group or gat­ed com­mu­ni­ty or demo­graph­ic, and land on the shaky plat­form of that idea of a good coun­try which all kinds of dif­fer­ent peo­ple share.

I believe deeply that this is a time for the next leap out of our “gat­ed com­mu­ni­ty or demo­graph­ic” onto that “shaky plat­form.” Maybe that plat­form isn’t even about a “good coun­try,” but more about a “good world.” We can’t go back­wards to rely on old rules no mat­ter how much we revere them. Instead we have to build on those rules and we have to decide for our­selves, defin­ing a more authen­tic Amer­i­ca that can be a real­is­tic part of our actu­al inter­de­pen­dent com­mu­ni­ty of nations, not some pro­tec­tion­ist fan­ta­sy of belong­ing to a pri­vate, “gat­ed” empire. I’m not sug­gest­ing a rev­o­lu­tion, just an effort to get our heads out of the sand. When I look at the can­di­dates, it seems such a clear deci­sion between past and future. One of them seems to me to under­stand much bet­ter than the oth­er how to cre­ate that bridge between our roots and the future we all have a respon­si­bil­i­ty to help define. I dear­ly hope you see things the same way.

Technorati Tag:
Published
Categorized as Choices

By Dan Oestreich

I am a consultant, coach, facilitator and trainer supporting the growth and development of leaders and teams. For further information about my work and services, please access my Oestreich Associates website.

1 comment

  1. Dan: thanks for shar­ing your calm­ing words dur­ing these trou­bled — and trou­bling — times. Your pho­to and sto­ry about a walk in the rain for­est reminds me of a quote by the poet, Wal­lace Stevens: “per­haps the truth depends on a walk around the lake”.

    I believe we always have fun­da­men­tal ten­sions with­in us — each with a thou­sand pilot lights that can eas­i­ly be fanned into the flames of inter­nal or exter­nal war. Recent incen­di­ary state­ments made by the McCain / Palin cam­paign, Fox News and oth­er sup­port­ers reflect the “win at any cost” strat­e­gy that has served the Repub­li­cans — but not the coun­try — well over the past few elec­tions. I hope that we can, as Hillary Clin­ton has recent­ly pre­dict­ed, once again “rise from the ash­es of the Bushes”.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.