On Self-Confrontation

One could almost say the heart of reflec­tive lead­er­ship is the capac­i­ty for self-confrontation.

It is not real­ly a skill. It is more a “psy­cho­log­i­cal move,” a men­tal and emo­tion­al re-posi­tion­ing to look very hon­est­ly at one­self and one’s sit­u­a­tion. With­out it, we have no way to accu­rate­ly judge or respond to sit­u­a­tions, espe­cial­ly when those sit­u­a­tions involve com­plex, real-world mis­un­der­stand­ings and con­flicts and the pow­er­ful emo­tions that go with them. 

DSC_0130

It’s eas­i­er to believe in self-con­fronta­tion when talk­ing about oth­er peo­ple. If only they would be hon­est with them­selves, things would get bet­ter. In real­i­ty, of course, each of us must be hon­est about our con­tri­bu­tions to the prob­lems, or the prob­lems between us sure­ly will con­tin­ue. Our mutu­al self-con­fronta­tions are the only way to with­draw from the per­sis­tent fan­tasies, assump­tions, and the pro­jec­tions you and I make onto each oth­er; to see things as they are. With­out this process of with­draw­al and under­stand­ing, how can I make the changes I need to make?

This seems straight­for­ward enough but the truth about our­selves can be a very del­i­cate (and slip­pery) thing, espe­cial­ly in those sit­u­a­tions that chal­lenge our blind belief that we’ve got a cor­ner on what’s true. We can be absolute­ly cer­tain of our expe­ri­ence of oth­ers only to dis­cov­er, too late, how wrong we were. And then, mak­ing the dis­cov­ery, we are pre­dictably bad at bal­anc­ing truth with self-care.

I recall work­ing some years ago with a client leader who had received some very tough feed­back about her style. She had days when her nat­u­ral­ly edgy style merged into sar­casm and ridicule of her asso­ciates. One day, after shar­ing some dif­fi­cult feed­back I’d col­lect­ed, I was help­ing her put togeth­er a per­son­al devel­op­ment plan. Over cof­fee she read her plan to me, then looked up from what she had writ­ten and spon­ta­neous­ly said — with that char­ac­ter­is­tic sar­casm in her voice — “Oh my! Now I’m apply­ing my very blind spots to writ­ing my plan! I’m writ­ing because I’m ful­ly con­vinced oth­er peo­ple are the only prob­lem I have.” She turned the paper over in front of her and gazed off thought­ful­ly, deeply per­turbed. I’d known her for awhile and it seemed to me she often used sar­casm to cov­er what was painful.

In it’s way, it was a beau­ti­ful moment of self-real­iza­tion — this see­ing the truth of how old habits put on new clothes to suit the cir­cum­stance, how with sleight-of-hand she was rein­vent­ing the very prob­lem our coach­ing rela­tion­ship was sup­posed to address. In an instant she had grasped her­self — but the acid was still there.

I helped her parse what she meant and then com­pli­ment­ed her on her dis­cov­ery, but with a doubt. What she had done to oth­ers she was now doing to her­self and I said as much to her. 

These many years lat­er, I still advise clients that the core of their work can depend on self-con­fronta­tion, but I guess I’ve learned (from my own expe­ri­ences as much as oth­ers’) that self-con­fronta­tion only real­ly works when it is wrapped in love. You can get to some part of the truth about your­self by pour­ing on the acid and watch­ing it eat away at the met­al of your own defens­es. You can say you are scared about some­thing and then crit­i­cize the heck out of your­self for it, cre­at­ing even more anx­i­ety. You can shame your­self for dis­re­spect­ing anoth­er, then beat your­self up mer­ci­less­ly. You can point to the mis­takes you’ve made as objec­tive truth and then use your ener­gy to numb out the pain — as if you could. Espe­cial­ly if you are sup­posed to be tough or per­fect or right all the time, the moment of self-knowl­edge can flat­ten you. But if you want the whole truth, you must open a lov­ing, redemp­tive, for­giv­ing door as well. You must acknowl­edge that whole truth as always big­ger than what­ev­er it was that flat­tened you. The love you need might come from a coach or a friend, but far bet­ter, of course, that it come from you yourself. 

When it comes down to it, the capac­i­ty to con­front your­self is more a part of love than the oth­er way around. 

I wish I’d reflect­ed some of that back more defin­i­tive­ly to my sar­cas­tic client. Maybe it just would have been in the tone of the com­pli­ment and the obser­va­tions I shared, or through some sub­tler aspect of pres­ence, metaphor­i­cal­ly pass­ing her a can­dle in the midst of her dark self-cri­tique. When you see some­one final­ly tell them­selves a truth, you know it for what it is, a hard moment. Maybe all you can do is offer sin­cere sup­port (“That’s a tough place to be!”) or qui­et­ly embrace the per­son, if they are okay with that. Some­times just being there is enough, unspo­ken love being the only kind at such a moment that can be heard.

DSC_0137

RSS and email sub­scrip­tion, month­ly Unfold­ing Lead­er­ship newslet­ter, search and oth­er func­tions may be found at the “Fur­ther Infor­ma­tion” tab at the bot­tom of this page.

By Dan Oestreich

I am a consultant, coach, facilitator and trainer supporting the growth and development of leaders and teams. For further information about my work and services, please access my Oestreich Associates website.

16 comments

  1. Anoth­er com­pas­sion­ate, and simul­ta­ne­ous­ly prob­ing and thought-pro­vok­ing post Dan. 

    Inner judg­ment is so easy for many of us…the crit­i­cal voic­es in our ear­ly years eas­i­ly become etched in our minds and play back like a tape recorder for the rest of our lives.…if we don’t know how to ignore those voic­es and replace them with a more com­pas­sion­ate one. 

    Per­son­al flog­ging real­ly don’t help. Flog­ging oth­ers does­n’t help either. I find that when I’m caught up in either, what I’m real­ly want­i­ng most is the acknowl­edg­ment that some­thing isn’t right…connection has been bro­ken or inter­rupt­ed, and I want things restored in some way. Not in the old way. A new and improved way but when that is mean­ing­ful for all involved. 

    Even when I’ve felt the most anger, under­neath it all, I want­ed some­one else to care enough about me and the sit­u­a­tion to want to make things right. More then I want­ed their punishment. 

    In the end, I don’t think all of us real­ly want to ‘get away’ with every­thing in life and nev­er be held account­able. Yet we do want the glance of mer­cy and com­pas­sion. We want to know that we are lov­able and still wor­thy of love when we make mistakes. 

    If we haven’t had very good compassion/mercy mod­els in life, it can take longer (if at all) for some­one to be able to learn how to have com­pas­sion for our­selves. With­out mir­ror­ing, humans just don’t know how to very well. (chil­dren severe­ly iso­lat­ed and abused with lit­tle human inter­ac­tion have revealed this as well as chil­dren found in the wild…) 

    We real­ly do need to mod­el com­pas­sion for one anoth­er just as much as we try to extend it to our­selves. We just can’t do it all on our own. 

    Again, love this post (as I usu­al­ly do) and this is what came up for me in the moment. 

    ~Saman­tha

  2. Dear Saman­tha~

    Your com­ments always touch me. You have a great heart, one that knows exact­ly how to speak with those chil­dren (all of us) found in the wild.

    Thank you, my friend, for your beau­ti­ful words.

    ~Dan

  3. Hi Dan,

    As usu­al a beau­ti­ful­ly writ­ten post from you. I always appre­ci­ate your belief on reflec­tions & enjoy your expe­ri­ence on same.

    Self reflec­tion is one path which is lit­tle unknown to most of us, and had it not been for nature we would have loved to ignore it for ever. Its a choice not many like to make, and its only because of THE LAW that gov­erns the uni­verse we are one day lead to the path of Reflec­tion. Peo­ple can’t escape their mir­ror how much they wish.

    I do under­stand your take on the pain involved with reflec­tion & that an asso­ci­at­ed feel­ing of love can be a great balm to it.
    It is when we see love as a sug­ar and that sug­ar becomes anoth­er coat on our new found belief that next reflec­tion hurts more when it tries to erode the that belief. Love will always be accom­pa­nied with hate, plea­sure will bring pain along.

    I do not have the answer only expe­ri­ence like you my friend & maybe that’s the path.

    Thank you for shar­ing your pro­found thoughts, enjoyed going through them and I agree that saman­tha “has a great heart, one that know how to speak.” God bless you both.

    Have a nice day. 🙂

  4. A heart­felt post and one that speaks deeply to me.

    I love this thought: self-con­fronta­tion only real­ly works when it is wrapped in love. and the capac­i­ty to con­front your­self is more a part of love than the oth­er way around. 

    All pro­found state­ments and yet some­times very hard to embrace. 

    Con­fronta­tion is not sim­ple. Look­ing in the mir­ror is not always pretty. 

    The heart of who we are is laced intro­spec­tion of self.

    The heart of who we want to become is the inter­sec­tion of who we are today and what what we will become tomorrow. 

    Self aware­ness, self con­fronta­tion is at the heart of all lead­er­ship. We each MUST lead from with­in if we want to get to the source of our soul. 

    Dan you are an excep­tion­al soul, when you con­front your­self BE PROUD. 

    Lol­ly Daskal
    Lead From Within

  5. Dear Gurmeet~

    Thank you so much for com­ment­ing. You raise such impor­tant points. It is easy to fall into the trap of believ­ing self-love can exist with­out self-con­fronta­tion. As you say, by nature the mir­ror is inescapable. It is pre­cise­ly because of this, I believe, that we must appre­ci­ate how oppo­sites arise from one anoth­er. When we know we can hold both sides — hap­pi­ness and suf­fer­ing, truth and decep­tion, beau­ty and ugli­ness, depth and super­fi­cial­i­ty — just as they are, a dif­fer­ent door opens, does­n’t it? To me, that is where real com­pas­sion lies.

    Thank you again, and you have a won­der­ful day, as well!

    Dan

  6. Dear Lol­ly~

    Thank you for adding such depth, Lol­ly. Com­ing through self-con­fronta­tion is like going through a nar­row place in one’s own life. On the oth­er side we can expe­ri­ence a moment of well-being and accom­plish­ment. That’s part of the love, too, hon­or­ing the will that got us through tight places.

    With grat­i­tude,
    Dan

  7. Thank you Dan, Learn­ing to appre­ci­ate how oppo­sites arise from one anoth­er is the key in my opin­ion. Jot­ting a cou­plet from a poem by great Sufi saint;

    “Ho Rab­ba koi mer­ay dil diyan kadraan pachanay!
    Mein sawali jin­na naheen koi sawal!!”

    “Oh Lord, if only some­one could under­stand the delib­er­a­tions of my heart!
    I am a seek­er who seeks nothing!!”

    You can check the full song here;
    http://lyricstranslate.com/en/hor-vi-neevan-ho-bow-your-head-further-down.html

    Thanks for the response.

  8. Dan,

    Incred­i­ble post. The abil­i­ty to look in the mir­ror, ask your­self tough hon­est ques­tions, and find answers with empa­thy is def­i­nite some­thing we should all mas­ter. We are first account­able for ourselves.

  9. Dear Gurmeet~

    Thanks for pass­ing along the song. I love the cou­plet you’ve shared. It reminds me of a poem by Anto­nio Machado…

    “Wan­der­er, the road is your
    foot­steps, noth­ing else;
    wan­der­er, there is no path,
    you lay down a path in walking.
    In walk­ing, you lay down a path

    and, when turn­ing around,
    you see the road you’ll
    nev­er step on again.
    Wan­der­er, path there is none,
    only tracks on the ocean foam.”

    Have a love­ly day, Gurmeet!

    ~Dan

  10. I can relate to many of the insights shared here, espe­cial­ly the way my “old habits put on new clothes to suit the cir­cum­stance”. Lessons are repeat­ed as often as necessary.

    I looked up the ety­mol­o­gy of “con­fronta­tion”: in Latin, con = “with, “front” = face … so per­haps “com­ing face-to-face with your self”.

    Thanks for high­light­ing the val­ue of com­pas­sion, and self-com­pas­sion, in work­ing through the shad­ows that often emerge when com­ing face-to-face with one’s self.

  11. Dear Joe~

    Yes, the lessons are repeat­ed. That is for sure. 

    I’m also try­ing to get at that dynam­ic of defen­sive­ness that real­ly is a rein­ven­tion of itself at a high­er lev­el. The very effort to over­come my defen­sive­ness trans­mutes itself into anoth­er “high­er” form of defen­sive­ness! There’s an infi­nite regres­sion here, defen­sive­ness defend­ing defen­sive behav­ior. To catch this process can cre­ate a moment of rare clar­i­ty and self-recognition.

    Thank you for stop­ping by, Joe! 

    All the best
    Dan

  12. Dan
    I ran across your recent post, with thought pro­vok­ing content.

    This reply is pri­mar­i­ly to say HELLO, a voice from your BELLEVUE con­nec­tion. I wish you well.

    Regards
    Dick Saunders

  13. Dear Dick~

    It’s great to hear from you! Work­ing at Belle­vue in the “Per­son­nel” Depart­ment seems likes eons ago — and it was, almost 24 eons.

    Many good wish­es to you for the Sea­son and New Year!

    ~Dan

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.