On White Knights

White knight is the term we might give any­one who rides in at the last moment, pulls order out of chaos, saves the king­dom and wins the love of the peo­ple with a spir­it of true virtue and inno­cence. In orga­ni­za­tions the term can be applied to any new col­league or leader who has an answer and an ide­al, an inspir­ing should. The term white knight can also apply to oth­ers, includ­ing and maybe espe­cial­ly con­sul­tants, who are there to save a work­place from some kind of dis­tress. (I know the role well).

The prob­lem with white knights is their naivety and their pen­chant for a lit­tle too much self-love, believ­ing so deeply in their ideals and good inten­tions that they cre­ate a blind spot about their own supe­ri­or behav­ior. They keep their clothes clean and stay out of the muck while gen­er­ous­ly diag­nos­ing prob­lems of good and evil, often good and bad lead­ers. In the end it’s no sur­prise the white knight often gets shot in the back for doing what seemed at the time to be the right thing. 

DSC_0196

This is the view of lead­er­ship as hero­ism, of course. We appre­ci­ate the ide­al­ism but spurn the nar­cis­sism. We yearn for res­cue but not a res­cuer who then takes home a tri­umph as a per­son­al possession. 

My per­son­al view of the real prob­lem with white knights is that they are fun­da­men­tal­ly unin­volved in the very thing they are sav­ing. As they see it, they are not guilty of hav­ing helped cre­ate the prob­lem they have rid­den in to solve. It is this lack of a human stain that begs for a more com­plex sto­ry, one in which the knight is thrown from the horse. It’s only then, after the fact, that the knight has a chance to “come to,” poten­tial­ly dis­cov­er­ing a dif­fer­ent kind of consciousness.

I think of a recent client, high­ly placed, specif­i­cal­ly engaged to bring deep tech­ni­cal change to an orga­ni­za­tion with a his­to­ry of lax con­trols, thick pol­i­tics, and con­sid­er­able waste. “I did this to myself,” he said to me hon­or­ably. “I put myself in this position.” 

What he was refer­ring to was how respon­si­bly he took on his charge, attempt­ing to sin­gle-hand­ed­ly bring the orga­ni­za­tion sys­tems and mea­sures that would help the whole place ratio­nal­ize the work. Months lat­er, how­ev­er, I’m called because his rep­u­ta­tion is in jeop­ardy. While peo­ple hon­or his innate knowl­edge and even bril­liance, many also feel he has called their com­pe­tence into ques­tion. He seems to lack the req­ui­site inter­per­son­al skills, espe­cial­ly to those with less stature. There is an atti­tude of dis­missal, a fail­ure to get back to peo­ple on the prob­lems they think are impor­tant while demand­ing rapid change on the prob­lems he does. My job seemed to be to con­vince him that being pulled off one’s horse could be a good thing, that the chal­lenge is a tru­ly soul­ful one. The prob­lem isn’t being a white knight, per se, but rather — I say in so many words to him — if you take a clos­er look at the muck into which you have fall­en, you then have a chance to dis­cov­er how your own per­son­al evo­lu­tion as a leader is part and par­cel of the work­place and orga­ni­za­tion­al changes that also need to be made.

We all have this part of us — the desire to act on oth­ers rather than to be with them as part of a shared strug­gle. It’s a tri­umph not so much of ego as a cul­tur­al­ly val­ued ana­lyt­i­cal mind­set that thinks rather mechan­i­cal­ly and puts too much empha­sis on the tech­ni­cal skills of the mechan­ic. But orga­ni­za­tions are not toast­ers or auto­mo­biles. Equip­ment does not reach up and grab you to say, “I don’t like the way you are turn­ing my screws.” Per­haps the screws do need to be turned, and in exact­ly this or that direc­tion, but peo­ple will nat­u­ral­ly defend them­selves from what they see as emo­tion­al harm. 

Many orga­ni­za­tions in the midst of need­ed changes face these prob­lems. Tech­ni­cal­ly cor­rect but emo­tion­al­ly destruc­tive, the lead­ers defend their actions based on the log­ic of need­ed changes, but can­not under­stand its impacts in human, soul­ful terms. In such an envi­ron­ment, the com­pro­mised white knight must learn to hon­or the muck, stop pre­tend­ing, vol­un­tar­i­ly get down off the horse, lis­ten to what peo­ple say they need, ask for advice, dis­play per­son­al learn­ing, and above all be vul­ner­a­ble. Hav­ing sat for awhile on the dung heap, that smarter white knight needs to do the “unthink­able” by both reach­ing in and reach­ing out.

RSS and email sub­scrip­tion, month­ly Unfold­ing Lead­er­ship newslet­ter, search and oth­er func­tions may be found at the “Fur­ther Infor­ma­tion” tab at the bot­tom of this page.

By Dan Oestreich

I am a consultant, coach, facilitator and trainer supporting the growth and development of leaders and teams. For further information about my work and services, please access my Oestreich Associates website.

18 comments

  1. I was once hired as a part of a team to BE the White Knight and save the cas­tle. Prob­lem is that there was so much pres­sure to fix, we nev­er had the time to under­stand. When we were above the dis­as­ter (that of course we did not start) we just saw the mess and ulti­mate­ly, we became a part of the mess as we chose to tin­ker instead of qui­et­ly find clar­i­ty in the chaos. 

    Insight­ful post, Dan and one that rings so true.

  2. HI Alli~

    I love this line, “there was so much pres­sure to fix, we nev­er had time to under­stand.” That’s a won­der­ful obser­va­tion about a trap that’s so easy to fall into! Many thanks for tak­ing a moment to share your expe­ri­ence and wis­dom, Alli.

    Many best wishes
    Dan

  3. Hi Dan,
    Your post deliv­ers the essence of what not so great lead­ers do … stay detached.

    Your mis­sive: “My per­son­al view of the real prob­lem with white knights is that they are fun­da­men­tal­ly unin­volved in the very thing they are saving. ” 

    Lead­ers who con­nect and can deliv­er both encour­age­ment and real­is­tic assess­ments unite teams in suc­cess. They move peo­ple past their own hangups and awak­en greatness.

    In that sense great lead­ers do res­cue the team from inner obsta­cles that could block success.

    Anoth­er tremen­dous post w/ imagery and poet­ry that takes us far.

    Thank you and best wishes!
    Kate

  4. Beau­ti­ful­ly writ­ten Dan. The thing about hav­ing ‘skin in the game’ comes to mind too. None of us, as soci­a­trists (organ­i­sa­tion­al helpers) or lead­ers can absent our­selves from the sys­tems we find our­selves in.

  5. I have found myself in the role of white knight before, both as self-appoint­ed and exter­nal­ly appoint­ed. It’s inter­est­ing — and hum­bling — to con­sid­er the shad­ow side of white knight­hood. I’m remind­ed of Stephen Cov­ey’s 5th habit, “seek first to under­stand, then to be understood”.

    I’m also remind­ed of a sto­ry I heard this morn­ing dur­ing my morn­ing com­mute from Tara Brach’s audio­book, Rad­i­cal Self-Accep­tance. She described an episode from the leg­end of Par­si­fal, one of the young Arthuri­an knights seek­ing the Holy Grail, who was instruct­ed by more senior knights not to ask any ques­tions of an ail­ing king. A sor­cer­ess con­vinces him to chal­lenge author­i­ty, and upon his sim­ply ask­ing the king “what aileth thee?”, the king is healed and pros­per­i­ty is restored to the kingdom.

    My take­away from that sto­ry — and the way I believe it relates here — is that ques­tion­ing, humil­i­ty and a gen­uine con­cern for the well-being of oth­ers are vital tools of any suc­cess­ful quest.

    Thanks for help­ing shed more light on the shad­ows and poten­tial gold of white knighthood!

  6. Dear Kate~

    Thank you, and I agree whole heart­ed­ly that lead­ers who can deliv­er real­is­tic assess­ments inte­grat­ed with encour­age­ment are posi­tioned to do great things. I believe that to do that, of course, you real­ly do have to be an insid­er to the issues, to feel and expe­ri­ence them and show the capac­i­ty for true empa­thy while help­ing lift the bar that every­one must car­ry. In doing so they inspire with their exam­ple, influ­ence with­out spe­cial tech­niques to do so, and as you say, “res­cue the team from inner obstacles.”

    I very much appre­ci­ate all your con­tri­bu­tions here, Kate. It’s always a plea­sure to learn from you!

    Best
    Dan

  7. Dear Joe~

    It’s always so great to see your words here! I love the ref­er­ence to Par­si­fal, and Tara Brach’s book. The phrase that caught me on the pages you linked was this one from her: 

    “…no mat­ter how much we med­i­tate or pray, we still need oth­ers to help us dis­man­tle the walls of our iso­la­tion and remind us of our belong­ing. Remem­ber­ing that we are con­nect­ed to oth­ers and our world is the essence of healing.”

    Per­haps part of the les­son is that the White Knight who rigid­ly main­tains iso­la­tion, even with the best of inten­tions, will be inef­fec­tive. It takes a cer­tain amount of inner “sor­cery” to man­i­fest gen­uine, coura­geous engage­ment. The only way to heal the king­dom is to risk becom­ing part of it, to also heal as part of it, from the inside out. The corol­lary is that the Knight who refus­es to get down from the horse vol­un­tar­i­ly will be forcibly pulled off. With­out that hap­pen­ing there’s no hope of true heal­ing for anybody.

    All the best and thanks again, Joe, for stop­ping by with your usu­al acute observations!

    Dan

  8. Once again, anoth­er bril­liant post high­light­ing part of the root cause behind what cur­rent­ly ails and plagues us as a society… 

    These are my favorite quotes from you post which so hap­pen to remind me of a movie I watched just the oth­er night with my daugh­ters. Ender’s Game. 

    The prob­lem with white knights is their naivety and their pen­chant for a lit­tle too much self-love, believ­ing so deeply in their ideals and good inten­tions that they cre­ate a blind spot about their own supe­ri­or behavior. 

    We appre­ci­ate the ide­al­ism but spurn the nar­cis­sism. We yearn for res­cue but not a res­cuer who then takes home a tri­umph as a per­son­al possession. 

    My per­son­al view of the real prob­lem with white knights is that they are fun­da­men­tal­ly unin­volved in the very thing they are sav­ing. As they see it, they are not guilty of hav­ing helped cre­ate the prob­lem they have rid­den in to solve. 

    We all have this part of us — the desire to act on oth­ers rather than to be with them as part of a shared struggle.

    Tech­ni­cal­ly cor­rect but emo­tion­al­ly destruc­tive, the lead­ers defend their actions based on the log­ic of need­ed changes, but can­not under­stand its impacts in human, soul­ful terms.

    Ender’s Game would be a per­fect ‘imag­i­nary’ case study on this whole top­ic of white knights and how we groom them. How WE are groomed to either be one our­selves and/or groom oth­ers to fill that role. This isn’t so much about who is to BLAME for it…that’s not real­ly so impor­tant as to under­stand that our beliefs we’ve cre­at­ed col­lec­tive­ly stem around this hero mod­el and image. 

    On the one hand, the good hero/heroine taps into sig­nif­i­cance that we each need to know and feel on an exper­en­tial lev­el in life. We need to believe that we mat­ter. That each one of us has a pur­pose in life that is an impor­tant part of the col­lec­tive whole. Yet bal­anced with a real­is­tic under­stand­ing that there is no sin­gle soli­tary per­son that can SAVE the whole, or is more IMPORTANT then the whole, although some­one may be inher­ent­ly gift­ed with skills that the major­i­ty of the col­lec­tive may not pos­sess. Such as the case of a savant or extreme­ly UNIQUE tal­ent or intelligence. 

    On the oth­er hand, we also need to col­lec­tive­ly under­stand how the pow­ers that be inten­tion­al­ly (and unin­ten­tion­al­ly) prey upon the egos of the mass­es to groom us to ful­fill their greed and meet needs. Exploit­ing the ego of some­one who is gift­ed and intel­li­gent like Ender was in order to build up cer­tain aspects of his psy­che so he could do the task they need­ed him to do. 

    Nar­cis­sism is alive and well in the world, and the inter­net has enhanced our ten­den­cy to feed this side of our­selves. We can SAY any­thing in order to manip­u­late peo­ple to do what we want, we are so con­di­tioned to believe the words before we expe­ri­ence any real mod­el­ing in action. 

    I’ve men­tioned this before in the pass a time or two when tweet­ing.. how the con­cept of lead­er­ship itself con­tains a trap from the out­set, in that in order to buy into the con­cept of lead­er­ship AT ALL, we must believe that we are supe­ri­or to oth­ers and that anoth­er per­son or group is infe­ri­or to ourselves. 

    Ok…so I real­ize we aren’t get­ting rid of the word or sys­tem any time soon. It’s more of a recog­ni­tion then any­thing else. 

    WONDERFUL post my friend. Thanks for sharing.

  9. Dear Saman­tha~

    What a great com­ment! You chal­lenge us “to go up a lev­el” in our aware­ness of how white knights are part of a larg­er sys­tem, how we are seduced into becom­ing them in order to hold fan­tasies of pur­pose while serv­ing oth­ers with less ster­ling motives. As you say, this is most­ly a mat­ter of recog­ni­tion, con­scious­ness being an anti­dote for the sub­tle drug of narcissism.

    Thank you so much, my friend!

    Dan

  10. What a keen reminder to get involved in the things we want to improve. Yes — we CAN become the change — and oth­ers see it in our tone and actions mod­eled. Thanks Dan!!!! Best, Ellen

  11. AMEN Dan!!!

    Your words that are worth repeating…

    Many orga­ni­za­tions in the midst of need­ed changes face these prob­lems. Tech­ni­cal­ly cor­rect but emo­tion­al­ly destruc­tive, the lead­ers defend their actions based on the log­ic of need­ed changes, but can­not under­stand its impacts in human, soul­ful terms. In such an envi­ron­ment, the com­pro­mised white knight must learn to hon­or the muck, stop pre­tend­ing, vol­un­tar­i­ly get down off the horse, lis­ten to what peo­ple say they need, ask for advice, dis­play per­son­al learn­ing, and above all be vul­ner­a­ble. Hav­ing sat for awhile on the dung heap, that smarter white knight needs to do the “unthinkable” by both reach­ing in and reach­ing out.. 

    Let us spread your mes­sage… it needs to be heard!

    Love this article.
    Lolly

  12. Dan,

    A very insight­ful post. A key insight is that the white knight lead­ers are also the ones who cre­at­ed the sit­u­a­tion. Some may look at the white knights of sav­ing the siu­ta­tion yet the ones with the keen insight will see they were respon­si­ble for let­ting the sit­u­a­tion hap­pen. Whether bad cul­ture, incen­tives, process­es, etc., lead­ers need to take note of what they are cre­at­ing and adjust pri­or to the let­ting the “white knight moments” happen.

    Get­ting self-aware­ness right is a key lead­er­ship skill. All-in-all, this skill and prac­tice may be the only way to pre­vent the white knight syndrome.

    Thanks!

    Jon

  13. Dear Jon~

    You make such an impor­tant point, Jon, that some­times when white knights are invit­ed in it is because a leader does not want to face the sit­u­a­tion that he/she has let hap­pen. That’s a set-up for every­body and a dis­place­ment of where learn­ing needs most to occur. 

    Many times in my career it has been evi­dent that I’m being asked to resolve that kind of cir­cum­stance: sim­ply make the issues go away with­out the actu­al engage­ment of all those who par­tic­i­pate in cre­at­ing it. Then there is a del­i­cate dance and gen­tle work to help look at the entire con­text of a prob­lem — with the usu­al answer being that we are all con­trib­u­tors. The good news is that many lead­ers mak­ing small changes can effect larg­er, more last­ing change for an entire organization.

    All the best
    Dan

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.