The unexpected gripe session. The group complaint suddenly at your door. The meeting that weirdly goes wrong, with people becoming negative, angry, mistrusting, accusatory.
And then there’s the panicky follow-up and the recriminations and search for the guilty. Who was to blame for this? How did we get here? What do we do now?
All likely evidence of something under the surface that has gone on far too long.
There’s almost too much to say about this dynamic, precisely because it causes so much anxiety — personal credibility and the very basics of whether people can work together being on the line.
A first impulse may be one of repression, but the first answer is precisely to avoid repression, along with any form of retaliation. Instead, the better route is to curtail the hard line and step back. If you do, you’ll most likely see that what you are looking at is baseline culture, a stress response and stories that have been circulating for awhile so that the dark energy has gathered enough momentum to break onto the surface. It isn’t about one or two “bad apples” corrupting the barrel. It’s about specific, unresolved conditions and inadequate workplace relationships.
Conditions are the problems that have been festering. The changes made without input. The inequities in job assignments or pay. The sense of favoritism or sexism. The put-downs in the air. The perceptions and realities of unfairness related to how people feel they have been treated.
Relationships are the meta-problem. The problem of people not being heard about their conditions, feeling and believing that their input, even when asked for doesn’t count with those who can do something about the conditions. The problem of assumptions about intentions, particularly the intentions and motives of the leaders. The problem of not working together, not collaborating to address challenges. The problem of old-school culture that blames, blames, blames as leverage on both sides according to the age-old default laws of us versus them.
It’s enough sometimes to make the heart of any leader quake.
And, you know, after twenty years of working with dark energy, I’d say, wow, have we missed the boat or what? For dark energy can be the royal road to improvement and understanding, the beginnings of a true workplace community, if it is attended to in the right way.
Which is to say, non-defensively, as a hallmark of true leadership. Maybe the best and most distinguishing hallmark of all, begging the question, how well can you or I turn it around?
Many years ago I worked with the civilian branch of a police department of a small city government. The ten employees who made up this branch were in a constant state of turmoil until one day a forthright and very genuine deputy chief visited the operation. “What are the problems?” he asked, knowing there were plenty. He listened and listened. There were problems with employees not carrying their fair share of the work. There were problems with how people felt they’d been treated by a former supervisor. There were problems with pay, and many more. He listened and listened…well. And when the group was done, he showed that he had listened in the simplest way, but repeating back to people their concerns, accurately. He then proceeded without once questioning the veracity or motives of anyone in the group, with not even the slightest dismissal of any concern to lay out plans for addressing each of these problems along with his high expectations for solution. In some cases, he didn’t know exactly what to do, but he tasked individuals with finding answers — soon — to the problem assigned. He carried his authority firmly, but without a trace of rancor, even though some of the complaints could have been taken personally, even though they were sometimes expressed with passive-aggressive taunts. He could have reacted and defended instead of exploring and responding. It was his tone, you know, that carried most it — the I “believe in fairness, too” tone — and the “we’re better than this” tone — and the “we’re off track and we can get on track right now” tone. Firm, serious, affirming of the group and the need, and totally consistent with a humanistic, if paramilitary approach.
I’ve watch the same kind of thing go down elsewhere, in other kinds of environments, including private sector ones. In some, the leader actively induces the speaking up. It’s fearless and firm, setting a boundary, but it is also about ending the harm to people in order to get back to the real work, serving the mission and the customers. Anybody who has been there knows that the problem is not one-sided; it’s not all “management,” not all “employees.” There may have been egregious behaviors, some very serious — abusive language, stealing or lying. Core interventions may be required, up to and including disciplinary action or terminations, up to and including anybody, even managers. The point is that the leader is unflinching in personal commitment to constructive outcomes that not only address the conditions, but also build the relationships that defend against dark energy pooling and building up until it becomes a crisis and a poison that undermines what’s good about people.
The hardest of these circumstances is when the dark energy seems to be about you, the leader. Then repression and retaliation beg for lawsuits, trips to the HR function, EEOC complaints and union grievances. Oh sure, such things can be mired in distorted power dynamics and can be totally unfair. But true leaders get that. It is unfair. So what? You must come up a notch. Then listening becomes deep listening. Then responding means responding from a deepening heart. Such listening and responding is immune to bait, to sabotage, to blackmail. Instead, it defines not just a higher road as a form of personal superiority, but a higher road in terms of what all of us can be together, as learning partners in the truest sense of the term.
Then you know what real “inner work” is, and you respect it in a new way within yourself and, with compassion, within others.
If you refuse this call, sooner or later, the dark energy may very well swallow you though you may still find some success in the world. It will not necessarily swallow you all at once, but one day at a time you’ll have to defend against a bitterness. The bear eats you little by little — from the inside out.
Over all the hilltops
There is silence.
In the tops of the trees,
You feel
Hardly a breath.
The birds have fallen silent in the woods.
Simply wait.
Soon,
You too will be silent.
RSS and email subscription, monthly Unfolding Leadership newsletter, search and other functions may be found at the “Further Information” tab at the bottom of this page.


Dan,
Your poetic style takes this everyday “negativity in the workplace” post to a veritable “magic carpet” ride to transformational change.
By magic carpet, I am not suggesting tricks or flighty responses. I truly mean that turning deep dark energy into a positive workplace — with the inner hard work — can launch the magic of collaboration, innovation, and unforeseen success.
I work so much in the field of people skills to resolve conflict in the workplace, I feel uplifted by this post. It gives the topic the true attention it deserves.
I cringe when I read and hear so many leaders responding with that popular trigger — “stop whining” — and am warmed by your treatment of dark energy as the result of many unaddressed issues.
Bravo my colleague!
Kate
Dear Kate~
Thanks so much. The “stop whining” line is one I’d like to return to sender. Stop whining and stop hiding in your fantasy of what leadership and management entail. Deal with the reality that people are who they are and things are as they are, and that as a leader it’s your job to address what’s taking place.
I so appreciate your taking a moment to comment, Kate. All the best to you!
Dan
Thank you for bringing the dark energy of leadership into the light.
It is easier said then done when you express how to deal with dark energy.
Each of us has a story that has created our energy, at times we live in the darkness because it feels safer than living in the light.
It is easy to tell someone how else they NEED to be OR SHOULD be.
the fact that we have no patience for the whiners or the fact that we have no tolerance for the dark. Proves to us that we do not accept all parts of who we are.
Dark energy needs to be acknowledge. It needs to be recognized and sometimes it needs to be surrendered to.
As you say in your article, it maybe just needs to be heard. without judgment, without reaction.
To tell leaders, do this or do that, is not addressing what is really going on, I find it is a bandage to something deeper and darker.
Darkness is just the absence of light, find the light and darkness disappears.
Thanks for shedding light on an important topic.
Powerful post Dan and a great closing:
Over all the hilltops
There is silence.
In the tops of the trees,
You feel
Hardly a breath.
The birds have fallen silent in the woods.
Simply wait.
Soon,
You too will be silent.
— Goethe
Dan, I featured this post on the home page of the Employee Engagement Network.
Dear Dan,
This is a beautiful and poetic assessment of how dark energy works its way through systems.
And I love your description of how it can be (has been) dealt with effectively through firm, clear leadership.
As I listen to the dark and stormy complaints, whines and frustrations in organizations, couples and teams, I am always holding an ear towards what inarticulated question is lurking: “What will become of me/ us in this change?” “Where are we going?” “How are we being seen and how do we want to be seen?” “What will happen if I/we really grow?”
Wishing you and yours all the best as we head into the season of darkness.
Blair
Hi Dan,
Do you think there is dark & enlightened energy?
What a lovely post, Dan. And you’ve written about an important topic in such a mature and realistic manner…not a bunch of theory.
I was an FBI agent for 24 years, and your example of the police station encounter was spot-on…law enforcement tends to be paramilitary in its approach, and yet the deputy chief handled the situation in just the right way…people felt they were heard, even though he may or may not be able to change anything simply because of the bureauracy.
Acknowledging the dark side is essential, just as essential as the acknowledging the bright side…it’s just we prefer to deal only with the good stuff and hope the dark stuf will disappear into a corner. It doesn’t, though, and your post is a timely reminder.
Dear Lolly~
Thanks for stopping by. I very much appreciate your adding your own insights and perspectives on a complicated issue. Acceptance of all parts of self and others, and finding light rather than reinforcing the darkness, are certainly core principles of the work.
All the best
Dan
Dear David~
Thank you so much for your comment and the honor of being on your front page! I’m delighted you liked the article.
All the best
Dan
Dear Blair~
I love your gentle questions, especially “What will become of me/us?” The anxiety can be such a driving force on its own when people don’t know where to turn. Just bringing the background questions forward I imagine helps people cope much more effectively and begin to grow and take charge of their fate. Thank you so much for your refined wisdom, Blair.
All the best
Dan
Dear Gurmeet~
Who knows in an absolute sense? I do not. But in my dealings in organizations I do see a big difference in energies offered.
Recently I observed two leaders evaluating a meeting where many high level professionals had been talking about a project they were all participating in. One leader heard the people’s passion for their work and desire for positive outcomes for customers. The other leader, speaking of the very same meeting, focused on the people’s complaints and resistance to change. The two leaders heard the same words from the same mouths, yet they received such differing impressions. I think the leader who saw passion instead of complaints was better prepared to lift the group even higher.
For me personally, I know I can get an impression of a person’s motives, and then rightly or wrongly I judge.… Someone could ask me the question that you are asking, Gurmeet, and I might say (as I do with you now), “Well, this person wants to explore something important together.” But another time I might hear such a question from someone and say to myself, “This is only a trick or a trap. This person simply wants to debate and compete with me in order for me to come to a viewpoint like his own.” Whether I see enlightened energy or dark energy seems to be a product of what I myself project onto the conversation!
It is like the old Cherokee legend about two wolves. Which one wins the fight is the one we feed.
All the best
Dan
Dear LaRae~
I very much appreciate your kind comments about this post. I totally agree — there is theory and then there are people who’ve been there, as I know you have, and had to face a tiger or two. Experience is a fine teacher and maybe the only real one when it comes to dark energy in organizations.
Thank you again!
Dan