Dark Energy

The unex­pect­ed gripe ses­sion. The group com­plaint sud­den­ly at your door. The meet­ing that weird­ly goes wrong, with peo­ple becom­ing neg­a­tive, angry, mis­trust­ing, accusatory. 

And then there’s the pan­icky fol­low-up and the recrim­i­na­tions and search for the guilty. Who was to blame for this? How did we get here? What do we do now?

All like­ly evi­dence of some­thing under the sur­face that has gone on far too long.

There’s almost too much to say about this dynam­ic, pre­cise­ly because it caus­es so much anx­i­ety — per­son­al cred­i­bil­i­ty and the very basics of whether peo­ple can work togeth­er being on the line. 

A first impulse may be one of repres­sion, but the first answer is pre­cise­ly to avoid repres­sion, along with any form of retal­i­a­tion. Instead, the bet­ter route is to cur­tail the hard line and step back. If you do, you’ll most like­ly see that what you are look­ing at is base­line cul­ture, a stress response and sto­ries that have been cir­cu­lat­ing for awhile so that the dark ener­gy has gath­ered enough momen­tum to break onto the sur­face. It isn’t about one or two “bad apples” cor­rupt­ing the bar­rel. It’s about spe­cif­ic, unre­solved con­di­tions and inad­e­quate work­place rela­tion­ships.

Con­di­tions are the prob­lems that have been fes­ter­ing. The changes made with­out input. The inequities in job assign­ments or pay. The sense of favoritism or sex­ism. The put-downs in the air. The per­cep­tions and real­i­ties of unfair­ness relat­ed to how peo­ple feel they have been treated. 

Rela­tion­ships are the meta-prob­lem. The prob­lem of peo­ple not being heard about their con­di­tions, feel­ing and believ­ing that their input, even when asked for does­n’t count with those who can do some­thing about the con­di­tions. The prob­lem of assump­tions about inten­tions, par­tic­u­lar­ly the inten­tions and motives of the lead­ers. The prob­lem of not work­ing togeth­er, not col­lab­o­rat­ing to address chal­lenges. The prob­lem of old-school cul­ture that blames, blames, blames as lever­age on both sides accord­ing to the age-old default laws of us ver­sus them.

It’s enough some­times to make the heart of any leader quake.

DSC_0174

And, you know, after twen­ty years of work­ing with dark ener­gy, I’d say, wow, have we missed the boat or what? For dark ener­gy can be the roy­al road to improve­ment and under­stand­ing, the begin­nings of a true work­place com­mu­ni­ty, if it is attend­ed to in the right way.

Which is to say, non-defen­sive­ly, as a hall­mark of true lead­er­ship. Maybe the best and most dis­tin­guish­ing hall­mark of all, beg­ging the ques­tion, how well can you or I turn it around?

Many years ago I worked with the civil­ian branch of a police depart­ment of a small city gov­ern­ment. The ten employ­ees who made up this branch were in a con­stant state of tur­moil until one day a forth­right and very gen­uine deputy chief vis­it­ed the oper­a­tion. “What are the prob­lems?” he asked, know­ing there were plen­ty. He lis­tened and lis­tened. There were prob­lems with employ­ees not car­ry­ing their fair share of the work. There were prob­lems with how peo­ple felt they’d been treat­ed by a for­mer super­vi­sor. There were prob­lems with pay, and many more. He lis­tened and listened…well. And when the group was done, he showed that he had lis­tened in the sim­plest way, but repeat­ing back to peo­ple their con­cerns, accu­rate­ly. He then pro­ceed­ed with­out once ques­tion­ing the verac­i­ty or motives of any­one in the group, with not even the slight­est dis­missal of any con­cern to lay out plans for address­ing each of these prob­lems along with his high expec­ta­tions for solu­tion. In some cas­es, he did­n’t know exact­ly what to do, but he tasked indi­vid­u­als with find­ing answers — soon — to the prob­lem assigned. He car­ried his author­i­ty firm­ly, but with­out a trace of ran­cor, even though some of the com­plaints could have been tak­en per­son­al­ly, even though they were some­times expressed with pas­sive-aggres­sive taunts. He could have react­ed and defend­ed instead of explor­ing and respond­ing. It was his tone, you know, that car­ried most it — the I “believe in fair­ness, too” tone — and the “we’re bet­ter than this” tone — and the “we’re off track and we can get on track right now” tone. Firm, seri­ous, affirm­ing of the group and the need, and total­ly con­sis­tent with a human­is­tic, if para­mil­i­tary approach.

I’ve watch the same kind of thing go down else­where, in oth­er kinds of envi­ron­ments, includ­ing pri­vate sec­tor ones. In some, the leader active­ly induces the speak­ing up. It’s fear­less and firm, set­ting a bound­ary, but it is also about end­ing the harm to peo­ple in order to get back to the real work, serv­ing the mis­sion and the cus­tomers. Any­body who has been there knows that the prob­lem is not one-sided; it’s not all “man­age­ment,” not all “employ­ees.” There may have been egre­gious behav­iors, some very seri­ous — abu­sive lan­guage, steal­ing or lying. Core inter­ven­tions may be required, up to and includ­ing dis­ci­pli­nary action or ter­mi­na­tions, up to and includ­ing any­body, even man­agers. The point is that the leader is unflinch­ing in per­son­al com­mit­ment to con­struc­tive out­comes that not only address the con­di­tions, but also build the rela­tion­ships that defend against dark ener­gy pool­ing and build­ing up until it becomes a cri­sis and a poi­son that under­mines what’s good about people.

The hard­est of these cir­cum­stances is when the dark ener­gy seems to be about you, the leader. Then repres­sion and retal­i­a­tion beg for law­suits, trips to the HR func­tion, EEOC com­plaints and union griev­ances. Oh sure, such things can be mired in dis­tort­ed pow­er dynam­ics and can be total­ly unfair. But true lead­ers get that. It is unfair. So what? You must come up a notch. Then lis­ten­ing becomes deep lis­ten­ing. Then respond­ing means respond­ing from a deep­en­ing heart. Such lis­ten­ing and respond­ing is immune to bait, to sab­o­tage, to black­mail. Instead, it defines not just a high­er road as a form of per­son­al supe­ri­or­i­ty, but a high­er road in terms of what all of us can be togeth­er, as learn­ing part­ners in the truest sense of the term. 

Then you know what real “inner work” is, and you respect it in a new way with­in your­self and, with com­pas­sion, with­in others. 

If you refuse this call, soon­er or lat­er, the dark ener­gy may very well swal­low you though you may still find some suc­cess in the world. It will not nec­es­sar­i­ly swal­low you all at once, but one day at a time you’ll have to defend against a bit­ter­ness. The bear eats you lit­tle by lit­tle — from the inside out.

Over all the hilltops
There is silence.
In the tops of the trees,
You feel
Hard­ly a breath.
The birds have fall­en silent in the woods.
Sim­ply wait.
Soon,
You too will be silent.

— Goethe

DSC_0164 - Version 2

RSS and email sub­scrip­tion, month­ly Unfold­ing Lead­er­ship newslet­ter, search and oth­er func­tions may be found at the “Fur­ther Infor­ma­tion” tab at the bot­tom of this page.

By Dan Oestreich

I am a consultant, coach, facilitator and trainer supporting the growth and development of leaders and teams. For further information about my work and services, please access my Oestreich Associates website.

13 comments

  1. Dan,
    Your poet­ic style takes this every­day “neg­a­tiv­i­ty in the work­place” post to a ver­i­ta­ble “mag­ic car­pet” ride to trans­for­ma­tion­al change.

    By mag­ic car­pet, I am not sug­gest­ing tricks or flighty respons­es. I tru­ly mean that turn­ing deep dark ener­gy into a pos­i­tive work­place — with the inner hard work — can launch the mag­ic of col­lab­o­ra­tion, inno­va­tion, and unfore­seen success.

    I work so much in the field of peo­ple skills to resolve con­flict in the work­place, I feel uplift­ed by this post. It gives the top­ic the true atten­tion it deserves. 

    I cringe when I read and hear so many lead­ers respond­ing with that pop­u­lar trig­ger — “stop whin­ing” — and am warmed by your treat­ment of dark ener­gy as the result of many unad­dressed issues.

    Bra­vo my colleague!
    Kate

  2. Dear Kate~

    Thanks so much. The “stop whin­ing” line is one I’d like to return to sender. Stop whin­ing and stop hid­ing in your fan­ta­sy of what lead­er­ship and man­age­ment entail. Deal with the real­i­ty that peo­ple are who they are and things are as they are, and that as a leader it’s your job to address what’s tak­ing place. 

    I so appre­ci­ate your tak­ing a moment to com­ment, Kate. All the best to you!

    Dan

  3. Thank you for bring­ing the dark ener­gy of lead­er­ship into the light.

    It is eas­i­er said then done when you express how to deal with dark energy.

    Each of us has a sto­ry that has cre­at­ed our ener­gy, at times we live in the dark­ness because it feels safer than liv­ing in the light. 

    It is easy to tell some­one how else they NEED to be OR SHOULD be. 

    the fact that we have no patience for the whin­ers or the fact that we have no tol­er­ance for the dark. Proves to us that we do not accept all parts of who we are.

    Dark ener­gy needs to be acknowl­edge. It needs to be rec­og­nized and some­times it needs to be sur­ren­dered to. 

    As you say in your arti­cle, it maybe just needs to be heard. with­out judg­ment, with­out reaction. 

    To tell lead­ers, do this or do that, is not address­ing what is real­ly going on, I find it is a ban­dage to some­thing deep­er and darker.

    Dark­ness is just the absence of light, find the light and dark­ness disappears. 

    Thanks for shed­ding light on an impor­tant topic.

  4. Pow­er­ful post Dan and a great closing:

    Over all the hilltops
    There is silence.
    In the tops of the trees,
    You feel
    Hard­ly a breath.
    The birds have fall­en silent in the woods.
    Sim­ply wait.
    Soon,
    You too will be silent.

    — Goethe

  5. Dear Dan,
    This is a beau­ti­ful and poet­ic assess­ment of how dark ener­gy works its way through systems.
    And I love your descrip­tion of how it can be (has been) dealt with effec­tive­ly through firm, clear leadership.
    As I lis­ten to the dark and stormy com­plaints, whines and frus­tra­tions in orga­ni­za­tions, cou­ples and teams, I am always hold­ing an ear towards what inar­tic­u­lat­ed ques­tion is lurk­ing: “What will become of me/ us in this change?” “Where are we going?” “How are we being seen and how do we want to be seen?” “What will hap­pen if I/we real­ly grow?”
    Wish­ing you and yours all the best as we head into the sea­son of darkness.
    Blair

  6. What a love­ly post, Dan. And you’ve writ­ten about an impor­tant top­ic in such a mature and real­is­tic manner…not a bunch of theory.

    I was an FBI agent for 24 years, and your exam­ple of the police sta­tion encounter was spot-on…law enforce­ment tends to be para­mil­i­tary in its approach, and yet the deputy chief han­dled the sit­u­a­tion in just the right way…people felt they were heard, even though he may or may not be able to change any­thing sim­ply because of the bureauracy. 

    Acknowl­edg­ing the dark side is essen­tial, just as essen­tial as the acknowl­edg­ing the bright side…it’s just we pre­fer to deal only with the good stuff and hope the dark stuf will dis­ap­pear into a cor­ner. It does­n’t, though, and your post is a time­ly reminder.

  7. Dear Lol­ly~

    Thanks for stop­ping by. I very much appre­ci­ate your adding your own insights and per­spec­tives on a com­pli­cat­ed issue. Accep­tance of all parts of self and oth­ers, and find­ing light rather than rein­forc­ing the dark­ness, are cer­tain­ly core prin­ci­ples of the work.

    All the best
    Dan

  8. Dear David~

    Thank you so much for your com­ment and the hon­or of being on your front page! I’m delight­ed you liked the article.

    All the best
    Dan

  9. Dear Blair~

    I love your gen­tle ques­tions, espe­cial­ly “What will become of me/us?” The anx­i­ety can be such a dri­ving force on its own when peo­ple don’t know where to turn. Just bring­ing the back­ground ques­tions for­ward I imag­ine helps peo­ple cope much more effec­tive­ly and begin to grow and take charge of their fate. Thank you so much for your refined wis­dom, Blair. 

    All the best
    Dan

  10. Dear Gurmeet~

    Who knows in an absolute sense? I do not. But in my deal­ings in orga­ni­za­tions I do see a big dif­fer­ence in ener­gies offered. 

    Recent­ly I observed two lead­ers eval­u­at­ing a meet­ing where many high lev­el pro­fes­sion­als had been talk­ing about a project they were all par­tic­i­pat­ing in. One leader heard the peo­ple’s pas­sion for their work and desire for pos­i­tive out­comes for cus­tomers. The oth­er leader, speak­ing of the very same meet­ing, focused on the peo­ple’s com­plaints and resis­tance to change. The two lead­ers heard the same words from the same mouths, yet they received such dif­fer­ing impres­sions. I think the leader who saw pas­sion instead of com­plaints was bet­ter pre­pared to lift the group even higher.

    For me per­son­al­ly, I know I can get an impres­sion of a per­son­’s motives, and then right­ly or wrong­ly I judge.… Some­one could ask me the ques­tion that you are ask­ing, Gurmeet, and I might say (as I do with you now), “Well, this per­son wants to explore some­thing impor­tant togeth­er.” But anoth­er time I might hear such a ques­tion from some­one and say to myself, “This is only a trick or a trap. This per­son sim­ply wants to debate and com­pete with me in order for me to come to a view­point like his own.” Whether I see enlight­ened ener­gy or dark ener­gy seems to be a prod­uct of what I myself project onto the conversation!

    It is like the old Chero­kee leg­end about two wolves. Which one wins the fight is the one we feed.

    All the best
    Dan

  11. Dear LaRae~

    I very much appre­ci­ate your kind com­ments about this post. I total­ly agree — there is the­o­ry and then there are peo­ple who’ve been there, as I know you have, and had to face a tiger or two. Expe­ri­ence is a fine teacher and maybe the only real one when it comes to dark ener­gy in organizations.

    Thank you again!
    Dan

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.